• Link to Facebook
  • Link to Instagram
  • Link to LinkedIn
  • Secure Payments
Phone: 250-753-2202
Nanaimo Law | Heath Law
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Mission
  • Lawyers
  • Services
  • FAQ
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Make a Payment
  • Employment Opportunities
  • Personal Injury Lawyers
  • Click to open the search input field Click to open the search input field Search
  • Menu Menu

Directors’ Duties, Corporate Governance in British Columbia, and Personal Liabilities of a Director of a Corporation

Blog, Business and Commercial Law

For a company governed by British Columbia’s Business Corporations Act, SBC 2002, c. 57 (the “BCA”), the principal statutory duties of directors and officers are set out in s. 142(1).

When exercising their powers and performing their functions, directors and officers must:

• act honestly and in good faith with a view to the best interests of the company;
• exercise the care, diligence and skill that a reasonably prudent individual would exercise in comparable circumstances;
• act in accordance with the BCA and its regulations; and
• subject to the above, act in accordance with the company’s memorandum and articles.

The first two duties are the focus of this article.

They are separate obligations: the fiduciary duty concerns honesty, good faith, loyalty, conflicts of interest and the company’s best interests; the duty of care concerns the standard of prudence, diligence and skill expected in the circumstances. The Supreme Court of Canada has confirmed that these duties “are, in fact, distinct and are designed to secure different ends”: Peoples Department Stores Inc. (Trustee of) v. Wise, 2004 SCC 68 [Peoples] at para. 33.

Being a director does not protect a person from liability for breaching a statutory duty or for their own wrongful conduct. Whether a director is personally liable depends on the particular statute or legal claim and any available defences. Some statutes, such as those dealing with unpaid taxes and wages discussed below, make directors liable even where there has been no fraud or illegal conduct.

The fiduciary duty

A director’s fiduciary duty is owed to the company, not directly to its shareholders, creditors, employees or other stakeholders. In BCE Inc. v. 1976 Debentureholders, 2008 SCC 69 [BCE], the Supreme Court stated that “the directors owe a fiduciary duty to the corporation, and only to the corporation” at para. 66. The British Columbia Court of Appeal has likewise described the duty as owed “to the corporation alone, not its shareholders, creditors, or any other stakeholders”: Sonic Holdings Ltd. v. Savage, 2021 BCCA 441 [Sonic] at para. 30, quoting Roussy v. Savage, 2019 BCSC 1669 at para. 307.

Directors must exercise their powers for the benefit of the company as a whole.

They must not use their position to advance their personal interests, favour a particular shareholder at the company’s expense or pursue an improper purpose.
The fiduciary duty includes the obligation to act honestly and in good faith with a view to the best interests of the company. Good faith is part of that statutory fiduciary obligation, rather than a separate, freestanding duty.

The best interests of the company

The company’s best interests are not limited to immediate profits, short-term share value or the interests of a particular shareholder group. When determining what is best for the company, directors may consider its long-term interests and the effects of a proposed decision on relevant stakeholders.

The Supreme Court has recognized that directors may consider the interests of “shareholders, employees, creditors, consumers, governments and the environment”: BCE at paras. 38–40. Considering stakeholder interests does not create a separate fiduciary duty to advance those interests independently of the company’s interests. Rather, those interests may inform what is in the company’s best interests, including its long-term success, financial position, reputation, legal compliance and sustainability.

There is no fixed rule that the interests of shareholders, employees, creditors, the environment or another stakeholder group must always prevail. The appropriate analysis depends on the circumstances and whether the directors acted honestly and in good faith in what they reasonably considered to be the company’s best interests. As the Supreme Court stated, “there are no absolute rules”: BCE at para. 82.

The duty of care

The statutory duty of care requires directors to exercise the care, diligence and skill that a reasonably prudent individual would exercise in comparable circumstances. This is an objective test. A director is not excused because they lack relevant skill or experience. Courts consider the circumstances in which the decision was made, which may include the director’s role and what they knew. A director with professional expertise who fails to act on information they recognized as a problem may find it difficult to show they met the standard.

Directors are expected to inform themselves about material issues, review information reasonably available to them, ask appropriate questions, participate meaningfully in board deliberations and obtain professional or expert advice where the circumstances reasonably require it.
The standard does not require perfection.

Directors must assess the circumstances known, or that reasonably ought to have been known, at the time of the decision. A decision is not necessarily negligent merely because it later produces an unfavourable result.

Business judgment and deference to directors

Canadian courts recognize that directors must make business decisions involving uncertainty, risk and competing considerations. Courts will generally give appropriate deference to an informed and honest business decision that falls within a range of reasonable alternatives.

This deference does not replace the statutory standard of care or protect a decision made without the care, diligence and skill required by s. 142(1). Nor does business judgment protect dishonesty, bad faith, undisclosed conflicts, self-dealing or diversion of corporate opportunities. The Supreme Court has described the business judgment rule as according deference where directors have selected one of several reasonable alternatives: Peoples at para. 65; BCE at para. 40.

Conflicts of interest

Directors must identify and appropriately address conflicts between their personal interests and their duties to the company. Under ss. 147–153 of the BCA, a director or senior officer who holds a disclosable interest in a contract or transaction into which the company has entered or proposes to enter must disclose the nature and extent of that interest.

Section 153 adds a separate disclosure obligation. A director or senior officer must promptly disclose any office, property, right or interest that could create a material conflict with their duties or interests as a director or senior officer.

The BCA contains specific rules governing interested contracts and transactions. A transaction is not automatically invalid merely because a director has an interest in it, failed to disclose the interest, or the transaction was not approved by the directors or shareholders. The applicable statutory disclosure, approval, participation and fairness requirements must nevertheless be followed.

The B.C. Court of Appeal has described these provisions as a “complete code” for conflicts involving contracts or transactions in which a director or senior officer has a disclosable interest: Sonic at para. 70. However, they do not replace a director’s broader fiduciary duties, including the duty not to take a corporate opportunity: Sonic at paras. 80–81.

A conflicted director should not participate in a decision where participation would compromise the director’s ability to act in the company’s best interests. The BCA generally restricts a director who holds a disclosable interest from voting on the directors’ resolution to approve the contract or transaction. Whether the director should also abstain from deliberations or leave the meeting depends on the BCA, the company’s articles and the circumstances.

Corporate opportunities

Whether an opportunity belongs to the company depends on the circumstances. The question is whether the opportunity fairly belonged to the company. Although the case law is not entirely consistent, the Court of Appeal has said that, as a general rule, a director must make full disclosure and obtain the company’s consent before taking a corporate opportunity, even if the company could not have pursued it and the director did not act in bad faith: Takhar v. Phoenix Homes Limited, 2025 BCCA 152 at paras. 22, 37.

Risk management, reputation and long-term value

Directors should consider material risks affecting the company, including financial, operational, legal, regulatory, technological, cybersecurity, environmental and reputational risks. The appropriate level of oversight depends on the company’s size, business, industry, operations, regulatory environment and circumstances.

Risk oversight is not a guarantee that the company will avoid loss or adverse events. The board’s role is generally to ensure that material risks are identified, properly considered and addressed through appropriate policies, reporting processes, controls and management oversight.

Reputation may be relevant to the company’s long-term interests because reputational damage can affect customers, employees, financing, regulatory relationships, business opportunities and corporate value. Directors may take reputational considerations into account when determining what is in the company’s best interests.

Environmental, social and governance considerations may also be relevant where they affect the company’s legal obligations, operations, risks, reputation, stakeholder relationships or long-term sustainability. British Columbia law does not impose a universal, freestanding fiduciary obligation requiring every company to pursue ESG objectives or stakeholder welfare independently of the company’s interests.

Practical governance measures

To help directors meet their obligations, a B.C. company’s board should generally:

• maintain clear governance policies and appropriate reporting procedures;
• ensure directors receive timely and material information;
• document significant decisions, the information considered and the reasons for the decision;
• identify and address actual or potential conflicts of interest;
• obtain professional or expert advice where appropriate;
• review material financial, operational, legal, regulatory, cybersecurity, environmental and reputational risks;
• monitor compliance with applicable legislation, contracts, regulatory requirements and company policies;
• ensure the board’s composition and directors’ training are appropriate for the company’s business; and
• revisit important decisions and governance policies as the company’s circumstances change.

These measures are not substitutes for the statutory duties and do not guarantee that a decision is lawful or protected from challenge. They are practical means of supporting informed, honest and prudent decision-making.

Personal liabilities

A director does not become liable for a company obligation solely because they are a director. Personal liability may arise under a specific statute or where the director’s own conduct gives rise to a cause of action.

A director who breaches their fiduciary duty may face personal liability for loss the company suffers as a result of the breach. A director may delegate responsibilities to an officer or expert, but must exercise reasonable care in selecting and supervising the delegate.

Section 157 of the BCA gives directors some protection. A director who relied in good faith on financial statements, professional reports or other information listed in s. 157 may be protected from liability under s. 154 and treated as having met certain duties. A director is also protected from liability under s. 154 if they did not know, and could not reasonably have known, that the act or resolution breached the BCA.

A director may be personally liable on a contract if it is not clear that they signed it on behalf of the company. To reduce this risk, directors should ensure that the company’s full legal name appears on contracts and that they sign as a director or officer of the company. These steps help, but they do not guarantee that a director will avoid personal liability; the result depends on the contract and the circumstances.

Personal tort liability

Acting for the company, or believing they were acting in its best interests, does not protect a director from liability for their own wrongful conduct (a tort). However, a director is not liable simply because they hold office; the claim must be based on something the director personally did.

Creditors and bankruptcy

Directors do not owe creditors a fiduciary duty merely because the company is insolvent or nearing insolvency. Creditors may, however, have remedies against directors in some circumstances, including through the oppression remedy and specific statutory provisions.

The Bankruptcy and Insolvency Act (the “BIA”) deals with two separate issues. Under s. 95, a payment or transaction that prefers one creditor over others may be set aside by the trustee in bankruptcy. Under s. 101, the court may review certain dividends, share redemptions or purchases, and certain payments to directors or officers made before the bankruptcy, and may order the directors to repay those amounts if the conditions in that section are met.

Oppression remedy

Under s. 227 of the BCA, a shareholder may apply to court for relief from oppressive or unfairly prejudicial conduct. For this purpose, “shareholder” includes a beneficial owner and anyone else the court considers appropriate. The court’s permission (leave) is not needed to bring an oppression claim. Leave is needed only for a derivative action, which is a claim brought in the company’s name under ss. 232–233.

A court may make an oppression order against a director personally only if the oppressive conduct is attributable to that director and a personal order is fit in all the circumstances. It may be relevant that the director gained a personal benefit or increased control of the company, but neither is required: Wilson v. Alharayeri, 2017 SCC 39 at paras. 31, 50.

Specific statutory liabilities

Under s. 154 of the BCA, directors who vote for or consent to a resolution authorizing certain prohibited acts may be jointly and severally liable to repay the company any amount paid or distributed that the company has not otherwise recovered. These acts include paying a dividend when the company is insolvent or the payment would make it insolvent (s. 70(2)), purchasing or redeeming shares contrary to s. 78 or 79, and making a payment or giving an indemnity contrary to s. 163.

A director who was absent from the directors’ or committee meeting at which such a resolution was passed may be deemed to have consented to it. To avoid this, the director must deliver or mail a written dissent within seven days after learning that the resolution was passed. The s. 157 defences may also be available.

Securities laws can also make directors personally liable in specific situations. For example, under the B.C. Securities Act, the directors of an issuer at the time a prospectus is filed may be liable to purchasers for a misrepresentation in the prospectus. Different rules and defences apply to other claims, such as claims for misrepresentations in an issuer’s ongoing public disclosure (secondary market liability).

Tax liabilities

The Income Tax Act, Excise Tax Act, Canada Pension Plan and Employment Insurance Act impose director liability for specified failures to deduct, withhold, remit or pay amounts, subject to statutory conditions and defences. This does not extend to every amount the company owes to the Canada Revenue Agency.

The time limits vary by statute. Under s. 227.1(4) of the Income Tax Act, the CRA must start proceedings against a director within two years after the director last ceased to be a director. Under s. 323(5) of the Excise Tax Act, the CRA cannot assess a director more than two years after the director last ceased to be a director. The Canada Pension Plan and Employment Insurance Act contain similar rules that adopt parts of s. 227.1 of the Income Tax Act, with some changes.

A director has a defence if they can show that they exercised reasonable care, diligence and skill to prevent the failure to remit. The focus is on preventing the failure, not on trying to fix it afterwards: Canada v. Buckingham, 2011 FCA 142 at para. 40.

A director should also be aware of a company’s potential obligation to withhold income tax where an employee claims the s. 87 exemption under the Indian Act but the employment income is not, in law, situated on a reserve. A director may face personal liability for amounts the company failed to withhold and that the CRA has been unable to recover from the company. The applicable due-diligence defence should also be considered.

Unpaid wages and workplace safety

Under s. 96(1) of the Employment Standards Act (the “ESA”), a person who was a director or officer when an employee’s wages were earned or should have been paid is personally liable for up to two months’ unpaid wages for each employee. The ESA contains exceptions, including rules relating to compensation for length of service in specified insolvency circumstances, vacation pay that becomes due after the director or officer has ceased to hold office, and money remaining in an employee’s time bank after that person has ceased to hold office.

Under the Workers Compensation Act (the “WCA”), every director and officer must ensure that the corporation complies with the Act’s occupational health and safety provisions, regulations and applicable orders. If the corporation commits an offence, a director or officer who authorized, permitted or acquiesced in it also commits an offence. The WCA provides a due-diligence defence.

Separately, s. 217.1 of the Criminal Code imposes a legal duty on a person who undertakes, or has authority, to direct how another person does work or performs a task to take reasonable steps to prevent bodily harm to that person, or any other person, arising from that work or task. Director status alone does not establish that this duty applies.

Environmental liabilities

Environmental liability depends on the particular statute; there is no single due-diligence rule that applies to all environmental laws. In British Columbia, under the Environmental Management Act (the “EMA”), an employee, officer, director or agent who authorized, permitted or acquiesced in an offence committed by the company also commits that offence.

The EMA also makes current and former owners and operators of a contaminated site, and certain other persons, responsible for cleaning it up, subject to exceptions. A former director is not responsible simply because they held office; they must fall within one of the categories in the EMA, such as a previous owner or operator.

Reducing personal liability risk

A director may reduce the risk of personal liability by:

• properly fulfilling their duties as a director;
• becoming familiar with, and ensuring compliance with, applicable statutes, the company’s articles and other governing documents;
• carefully appointing and properly supervising officers and experts; and
• maintaining appropriate governance policies.

A company may also indemnify its directors and officers and buy directors’ and officers’ liability insurance for them, subject to the BCA. These are separate protections. Under s. 163, a company may not indemnify a director in certain circumstances, including where the director did not act honestly and in good faith with a view to the best interests of the company. Under s. 165, a company may buy insurance for its current and former directors and officers. Any coverage is subject to the terms of the policy.

Summary

For a company governed by the BCA, directors must act honestly and in good faith with a view to the best interests of the company and exercise the care, diligence and skill that a reasonably prudent individual would exercise in comparable circumstances.

The fiduciary duty is owed to the company. Directors may consider stakeholder interests, reputational concerns, ESG matters and long-term consequences when determining what is in the company’s best interests, but those considerations do not create independent fiduciary objectives that displace the company’s interests.

Courts generally give appropriate deference to informed, honest and reasonable business decisions. That deference does not protect dishonesty, bad faith, undisclosed conflicts, self-dealing, diversion of corporate opportunities or a failure to meet the statutory standard of care.

A director does not become liable for a company obligation solely because they are a director. Personal liability may nevertheless arise in specified circumstances, including under statutory provisions and for the director’s own actionable conduct. Directors should understand the duties and statutory liabilities that may apply to them and take appropriate governance, insurance and indemnification measures.

This article provides general information only and is not legal advice. The law may have changed since the date of publication.

Directors and officers should obtain legal advice about their particular circumstances.

November 5, 2026/by Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers
/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png 0 0 Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers /wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers2026-11-05 20:53:142026-11-05 20:53:14Directors’ Duties, Corporate Governance in British Columbia, and Personal Liabilities of a Director of a Corporation

Directors of BC Societies: Your Duties and Personal Liability

Blog, Business and Commercial Law

Thousands of British Columbians volunteer as directors of non-profit societies, community associations, sports clubs, charities, housing societies and more. Most take on the role to give back. Few realize that the position carries legal duties, and in some situations, personal liability.

This article explains, in plain terms, what the law expects of society directors in B.C. and where personal risk can arise.

The core duties

The Societies Act (B.C.) requires every director, when acting as a director, to:

• act honestly and in good faith, with a view to the best interests of the society;
• exercise the care, diligence and skill that a reasonably prudent individual would exercise in comparable circumstances;
• comply with the Societies Act and its regulations;
• follow the society’s bylaws, so long as doing so is consistent with the duties above; and
• act with a view to the society’s purposes, as set out in its constitution.

The first item is often called the fiduciary duty (a duty of loyalty). The second is the duty of care. The direction to act with a view to the society’s purposes is unique to societies and colours both.

Loyalty: whose interests come first?

A director’s loyalty is owed to the society itself, not to the members who elected them, the staff, funders, creditors or any particular group.

B.C.’s Court of Appeal has confirmed that the principles governing corporate directors apply by analogy to society directors. The Supreme Court of Canada has said that directors may and sometimes should consider how a decision affects employees, creditors, the community and other stakeholders. But that consideration informs what is best for the organization. It does not create a separate duty owed to each of those groups. There is no fixed rule that any one group’s interests must prevail.

For a society, one further point matters: the board’s view of the society’s “best interests” must line up with the society’s stated purposes. A board should not chase revenue, growth or a new direction that departs from the purposes in its constitution. If the purposes no longer fit what the society does, the proper course is to amend the constitution, not to drift away from it.

Care and diligence: perfection is not required

The duty of care asks what a reasonably prudent person would have done in the same circumstances, based on what the director knew or ought to have known at the time.

The Supreme Court of Canada has stressed that perfection is not demanded. Courts are reluctant to second-guess decisions with the benefit of hindsight. A decision is not negligent simply because it turned out badly. Under what is known as the “business judgment rule,” courts generally defer to a board’s decision if it falls within a range of reasonable choices and was made on an informed basis.

That deference has limits. It will not protect a board that failed to inform itself, nor will it excuse dishonesty, bad faith, self-dealing or an undisclosed conflict.

In practice, meeting the duty of care means:

• preparing for meetings and reading the materials;
• asking questions and following up when something seems wrong;
• taking an active part in decisions rather than deferring to others;
• getting professional advice (legal, accounting or other) when the issue calls for it; and
• making sure significant decisions, and the reasons for them, are recorded in the minutes.

Conflicts of interest: the rules are mandatory

Conflicts are one of the most common sources of trouble for society boards. Picture a director whose spouse’s company bids on a society contract, or a director who rents property to the society.

Where a director has a material interest, direct or indirect, in a contract, transaction or matter before the society that could conflict with their duty as a director, the Societies Act requires the director to:

1. disclose the nature and extent of the interest to the other directors, fully and promptly;
2. abstain from voting on it;
3. leave the meeting while it is discussed and voted on; and
4. refrain from trying to influence the discussion or vote.

The disclosure must be recorded, usually in the minutes.

These are legal requirements, not suggestions. There are narrow exceptions, including where every director has disclosed an interest in the same matter, and for routine matters such as director expense reimbursement, indemnities and insurance.

Profits must be repaid unless the transaction is properly approved. A conflicted director must pay to the society any profit made from the transaction unless they followed the disclosure rules and the transaction was then approved by the other directors, or the members approved it by special resolution after full disclosure.

A conflicted transaction is not automatically void. But if it was not properly approved, a court can stop it or set it aside if it was not reasonable and fair to the society.

Can I be personally liable?

The short answer: not simply for being a director. A society is a separate legal entity, and its debts and obligations are its own. Personal exposure arises in two main ways: under specific statutes or because of the director’s own conduct.

A few general points:

• No contracting out. Neither the bylaws nor a contract can relieve a director of the duty to comply with the Societies Act, or of liability for negligence, breach of duty or breach of trust.
• Acting like a director counts. A person who is not formally a director but performs a director’s functions may be held to the same duties.
• Breach of loyalty. A director who breaches the duty of loyalty may be ordered to compensate the society and, in appropriate cases, to give up profits made through the breach, even if the society itself suffered no loss.
• Your own wrongful acts. A director is not liable for the society’s wrongs merely because of their title. But the Court of Appeal has confirmed that people remain responsible for their own wrongful conduct, even when acting in good faith on the organization’s behalf.
• Signing documents. Make sure contracts name the society as the party and show that you are signing on its behalf. Get advice before signing any personal guarantee.

Improper distributions

Directors who vote for, or consent to, a resolution authorizing a distribution of money or property contrary to the Societies Act or the bylaws are jointly and severally liable to repay it to the society. A director has a defence if they relied in good faith and reasonably on financial statements, professional reports or similar information. Claims must be brought within two years of the resolution.

Financial difficulty and insolvency

Directors do not owe creditors a fiduciary duty, even when the society is insolvent or close to it. However, if the society goes bankrupt, the trustee can unwind certain payments made in the months before bankruptcy that preferred one creditor over others: three months for arm’s-length creditors and twelve months for related parties. Boards facing financial difficulty should get advice early.

Member complaints

A member who believes the society’s affairs have been conducted oppressively, or that a resolution is unfairly prejudicial to them, may apply to court. The court has broad powers, including removing a director, setting aside a transaction or ordering compensation. Separately, a member or director may ask the court for permission to sue in the society’s name, for example, to pursue a claim against a director on the society’s behalf.
Specific statutory liabilities

Several statutes make directors personally responsible for particular unpaid amounts. Each is limited in scope, and most offer a due diligence defence: a director who took reasonable steps to prevent the failure is not liable.

What Law Scope and limits

Unpaid wages Employment Standards Act (B.C.)

Up to two months’ unpaid wages per employee. A B.C. court has held this does not extend to wrongful dismissal damages.

Source deductions (income tax, CPP, EI) Income Tax Act (Canada) Only amounts the society failed to withhold or remit. Due diligence defence; claims barred two years after the director leaves office.

GST/HST Excise Tax Act (Canada) Only net tax the society failed to remit. Due diligence defence; two-year limit after leaving office.

WorkSafeBC assessments Workers Compensation Act (B.C.) Applies only in specified circumstances; whether it reaches a particular society should be checked. Due diligence defence.

The practical lesson: the board should regularly confirm that payroll, source deductions and GST/HST remittances are current, and should act immediately if they fall behind.

Protection: indemnities and insurance

A society may indemnify its directors and pay their legal costs if they are sued because of their role, subject to the Societies Act and any limits in the bylaws. In some cases, once a proceeding is over and the director has not been found at fault, the society must reimburse their expenses. A society may also advance legal costs during a proceeding, but only after receiving a written promise to repay them if repayment is later required.

There are firm limits. A society cannot indemnify a director who did not act honestly and in good faith in the society’s best interests. If the claim is brought by the society itself, court approval is needed before the society can indemnify.

A society may also buy directors’ and officers’ (D&O) liability insurance. Coverage depends on the policy wording, so boards should review it with their broker. Prospective directors should consider whether the society has D&O insurance before agreeing to serve.

A practical checklist for society directors

• Read the society’s constitution, bylaws and recent minutes and financial statements.
• Know the society’s purposes and keep decisions consistent with them.
• Come prepared to meetings, ask questions and insist on timely information.
• Declare conflicts early, have them minuted, and step out when required.
• Record significant decisions and the reasons for them.
• Monitor finances, especially payroll, source deductions and GST/HST remittances.
• Get professional advice when an issue is beyond the board’s expertise.
• Confirm the society has appropriate indemnity provisions and D&O insurance.
• Never sign a personal guarantee without independent advice.

Serving on a society board is rewarding, and the legal risk for a careful, engaged director is modest. Understanding the rules is the best protection.

This article provides general information only and is not legal advice.

November 3, 2026/by Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers
/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png 0 0 Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers /wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers2026-11-03 15:51:352026-11-14 16:44:22Directors of BC Societies: Your Duties and Personal Liability

What Should Be Found In A Franchise Disclosure Document?

Blog, Business and Commercial Law

Before a person buys a franchise, there is certain information they will want to have. A franchisor must provide a potential franchisee with a Franchise Disclosure Document that contains particular information and meets a specified form, as per the BC Franchises Act, SBC 2015, c 35. This article outlines basic information necessary to understand what must be included in a Franchise Disclosure Document.

Background

Under the Franchises Act, franchisors must provide potential franchisees with a disclosure document at least 14 days before either the signing by the prospective franchisee of the franchise agreement, or the payment by the prospective franchisee of any consideration relating to the franchise (whichever is earlier). This disclosure document must be delivered as one complete document, at one time. A disclosure document must contain all material facts, and the following:

  • prescribed financial statements;
  • copies of all proposed franchise agreements, and other agreements relating to the franchise, to be signed by a prospective franchisee;
  • prescribed statements that have the purpose of assisting a prospective franchisee to make informed investment decisions;
  • other prescribed information;
  • copies of other prescribed documents.

A franchisor must also keep the potential franchisee up to date by providing them with a written statement of any material change. The potential franchisee must receive this statement as soon as practicable after the change has occurred and before the signing of the franchise agreement, or the payment of any consideration relating to the franchise (whichever is earlier).

Prescribed Information

Under the Franchises Regulation, BC Reg 238/2016, a Franchise Disclosure Document must specifically contain the information below.

Risk warning statements

Presented together at the beginning of the document, the following statements:

A prospective franchisee should seek information on the franchisor and on the franchisor’s business background, banking affairs, credit history and trade references.

A prospective franchisee should seek expert independent legal and financial advice in relation to franchising and the franchise agreement before entering into the franchise agreement.

A prospective franchisee should contact current and previous franchisees before entering into the franchise agreement.

Lists of current and previous franchisees and their contact information can be found in this disclosure document.

Dispute resolution description

Requirements under the franchise agreement with respect to arbitration, mediation or other alternative dispute resolution processes, including requirements relating to location.

Financial statements

Financial statements of the franchisor that are prepared in accordance with the generally accepted accounting principles of the jurisdiction in which the franchisor is based. The financial statements of the franchisor must be either audited in accordance with the generally accepted auditing standards or reviewed in accordance with the generally accepted standards that are applicable to review engagements. The financial statements must be for the most recently completed year, unless an exception applies.

Required information about the franchisor

  • the business background of the franchisor;
  • the business background of the directors, the officers and the general partners;
  • previous convictions and pending charges of the franchisor, the franchisor’s associate or a director, an officer or a general partner;
  • whether, during the 10-year period immediately preceding the date of the disclosure document, the franchisor, the franchisor’s associate or a director, an officer or a general partner of the franchisor was subject to an administrative order or penalty;
  • whether, during the 10-year period immediately preceding the date of the disclosure document, the franchisor, the franchisor’s associate or a director, an officer or a general partner of the franchisor was found liable in a civil action for misrepresentation or engaging in unfair or deceptive business practices;
  • details of any bankruptcy or insolvency proceedings, any part of which took place during the 6-year period immediately preceding the date of the disclosure document.

Required information about the franchise

  • costs of establishing the franchise and other fees;
  • the franchisor’s policies and practices, if any, regarding guarantees and security interests required of franchisees;
  • estimate of operating costs;
  • earnings projection;
  • the terms and conditions of any financing arrangements that the franchisor offers;
  • a description of any training offered to the franchisee by or on behalf of the franchisor;
  • if the franchisee will be required to operate in accordance with manuals provided by the franchisor, the table of contents of each manual or information about where the manuals can be found;
  • information about advertising, if the franchisee will be required to contribute to an advertising fund;
  • purchase and sale restrictions;
  • rebates, commissions, payments or other benefits;
  • the franchisee’s rights to the territory, if there are any;
  • trademarks and other proprietary rights;
  • licences, registrations, authorizations and other permissions;
  • a description of the extent to which the franchisee will be required to participate personally and directly in the operation of the franchise;
  • a list of all the provisions in the franchise agreement that deal with the termination of the franchise agreement, the renewal of the franchise agreement and the transfer of the franchise.

Lists of franchisees, businesses and closures

  • a list of all franchisees of the franchisor or of the franchisor’s affiliates that currently operate franchises in Canada of the same type as the franchise being offered, including the name, business address and telephone number of each franchisee;
  • a list of all businesses of the same type as the franchise being offered that the franchisor or the franchisor’s affiliates currently operate in Canada, including the name and business address of each business;
  • a list of all former franchisees of the franchisor or of the franchisor’s affiliates that previously operated, in Canada and, if applicable, in any foreign jurisdiction;
  • the total number of franchises in Canada of the franchisor or of the franchisor’s affiliates of the same type as the franchise being offered within the previous 3 fiscal years that have
    • been terminated or cancelled by the franchisor or the franchisor’s affiliates,
    • not been renewed by the franchisor or the franchisor’s affiliates,
    • been reacquired by the franchisor or the franchisor’s affiliates, or
    • not been renewed by the franchisee or otherwise left the franchise system.
September 28, 2026/by Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers
/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png 0 0 Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers /wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers2026-09-28 11:30:372026-09-25 11:41:54What Should Be Found In A Franchise Disclosure Document?

Employee vs. Independent Contractor: Tax Considerations

Blog, Business and Commercial Law, Employment Law

Many professionals are choosing to structure their services through a corporation, often working as independent contractors rather than direct employees. This approach can offer significant tax benefits that surpass the limited options available to employees. However, before jumping into incorporation, it’s crucial to understand the potential tax consequences, especially if you’re providing services to an entity that would otherwise employ you directly.

Employee vs. Independent Contractor

The key to determining whether you’re an employee or an independent contractor lies in whether you’re running your own business or simply working for an employer.

Here are some factors to consider:

1. Intention: What was the original agreement or understanding between you and the company?

2. Control: How much control does the company have over how and when you work?

3. Equipment: Do you supply your own tools and equipment, or does the company provide them?

4. Financial Risk: Are you taking on financial risk, like investing in equipment or covering expenses?

5. Opportunity to Profit: Do you have a chance to earn extra income based on your performance and efficiency?

Understanding the Tax Implications

Incorporating your business can offer tax advantages, but it also comes with important considerations. The Income Tax Act has rules to prevent tax avoidance through incorporation. A significant provision is the Anti-Avoidance Rule, which applies if you incorporate your business to provide services that would normally be done as an employee. In such cases, your corporation might be categorized as a personal service business.

Personal Service Business: What You Need to Know

If classified as a personal service business, you’ll face several tax disadvantages:

1. Restricted Deductions: You’ll have limited ability to deduct common business expenses like office supplies, travel, meals, and phone bills.

2. Loss of Small Business Deduction: You won’t be eligible for the small business deduction, which usually provides a lower tax rate.

3. Higher Tax Rate: Personal service businesses are subject to a higher tax rate—specifically 5% of the corporation’s taxable income for the year.

Conclusion

If you’re considering incorporating as an independent contractor, please contact Heath Law to book and appointment with one of our lawyers for legal advice and seek out a tax professional to avoid unexpected tax issues.

 

September 13, 2024/by Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers
/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png 0 0 Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers /wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers2024-09-13 19:22:262024-09-16 14:22:17Employee vs. Independent Contractor: Tax Considerations

Litigation Privilege – What About Communications Amongst the Board of Directors?

Blog, Business and Commercial Law, Litigation

Does Litigation Privilege Apply to Communications Amongst the Board of Directors?

Litigation privilege prevents a party to litigation from having to disclose documents that were made in anticipation of or for the purpose of litigation. Litigation privilege ensures the efficacy of Canada’s adversarial process by giving parties a “zone of privacy” to conduct investigations and prepare for litigation.[1]

While solicitor-client privilege is broader in scope, litigation privilege is distinct in that it is not limited to confidential communications between a solicitor and client. Litigation privilege does not require a solicitor to be a party to the communications whatsoever. However, the courts have noted that litigation privilege, in comparison to solicitor-client privilege, is “less absolute, more fact-driven and subject to challenge.”[2]

A pertinent question then arises: does litigation privilege protect communications among directors of a corporation or society?

Litigation Privilege Criteria

The short answer is it depends. For litigation privilege to apply, the party asserting privilege must establish for each document over which privilege is being claimed:

(1) that litigation was ongoing or was reasonably contemplated at the time the document was created; and

(2) that the dominant purpose of creating the document was to prepare for that litigation.[3]

The two-prong test is objectively assessed, meaning very little consideration is given to the party’s subjective thoughts. The first prong of the test is assessed by asking: “Would a reasonable person being aware of the circumstances conclude that the claim will not likely be resolved without litigation?”[4] The analysis of the second prong is fact-driven, focusing on the surrounding circumstances in which the document was created.[5] Considerations in this analysis include “when [the document] was created, who created it, …and what use was or could be made of it.”[6]

How to Protect Directors’ Correspondence

If directors intend to rely on litigation privilege to protect their correspondence, they must ensure that the documents are created in the face of litigation, and that the dominant purpose of the documents is for the impending litigation. It is prudent practice for directors to specify that the dominant purpose of the document is for litigation. Additionally, directors should avoid including disparaging or irrelevant comments in the correspondence to maintain the dominant purpose of litigation.

[1] Blank v Canada (Minister of Justice), 2006 SCC 39 at paras. 27 and 34.
[2] Stone v Ellerman, 2009 BCCA 294 at para. 27.
[3] Gichuru v British Columbia (Information and Privacy Commissioner), 2014 BCCA 259 at para. 32.
[4] Raj v Khosravi, 2015 BCCA 49 at para. 11.
[5] Ibid, at para. 17.
[6] Birring Development Co. Ltd. v Binpal, 2021 BCSC 1298 at para. 31.

 

Contact Heath Law in Nanaimo for any questions.

July 12, 2024/by Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers
/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png 0 0 Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers /wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers2024-07-12 17:44:512024-07-12 17:45:09Litigation Privilege – What About Communications Amongst the Board of Directors?

Understanding the Short-Terms Rental Accommodations Act of British Columbia

Blog, Business and Commercial Law, Real Estate

How BC’s Short-Term Rental Accommodations Act Affects Your Property

The government of British Columbia has recently enacted new legislation regarding short-term rentals. The Short-Term Rental Accommodations Act (the “Act”) came into effect in October 2023 and will continue to be rolled out over the course of two years. The primary aim of the Act is to address the housing shortage by transitioning short-term rental units into long-term housing options. However, there are certain exemptions to the new legislation including hotels, motels, student accommodations, as well as ski and resort regions, and farmlands.

A short-term rental is defined as the service of accommodation by a property host, in exchange for a fee, that is provided to members of the public for a period of less than 90 consecutive days. The Act limits short-term rentals to where the host utilizes the property as their principal residence, meaning they reside at the residence for a longer period of time in a calendar year than any other place. Further, the property host may offer for rent a secondary suite or an accessory dwelling unit where the property is the host’s principal residence. The principal residence requirement applies to communities with a population higher than 10,000 people, including smaller neighbouring communities. Communities such as Tofino and Whistler are not included in the principal residence requirement, however, their local governments may choose to opt-in to include this requirement.

The Act also imposes obligations on the host of short-term rentals as well as the platform service providers, such as Airbnb and VRBO, to be registered with the province. The host must include their provincial registration number, and where applicable, a business licence number on the rental listing.

The Act will have impacts on short-term rentals found on Airbnb, VRBO and other platforms, however, rentals will still be available where the property is the principal residence of the host. Where it is the principal residence, the host can rent the property, as well as one secondary suite or one accessory dwelling unit.

Do you have questions about turning your primary residence into a short-term rental, or how the Act affects secondary properties? Contact Heath Law to schedule your consultation.

*This blog is up to date as of June 1, 2024*

June 18, 2024/by Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers
/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png 0 0 Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers /wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers2024-06-18 10:50:342024-06-18 14:18:48Understanding the Short-Terms Rental Accommodations Act of British Columbia

What annual documents need to be prepared for a corporation in B.C.?

Blog, Business and Commercial Law

Key Annual Obligations for Corporations in British Columbia

The British Columbia Business Corporations Act (BCA) requires all corporations to file an annual report with the registrar, pursuant to section 51 of the Act. By filing your annual report, you are informing the B.C. Registry that your company is in active standing. A failure to file an annual report after two consecutive years may result in company dissolution. This post looks at important annual maintenance responsibilities and obligations of a corporation.

Annual Reference Date and Annual General Meeting

Section 1(1) of the BCA describes the annual reference date as the date when the next general meeting is to be held. This date is to be one year from the previous annual general meeting or before as approved by shareholders which needs to be filed in the annual general meeting.

The BCA requires that a corporation hold an annual general meeting every year, within two months after each anniversary of the date on which the company was recognized. At the meeting, the directors are to provide financial statements as well as any auditor’s report on the financial statements. Note that the BCA does allow all shareholders to vote on a resolution to waive an annual general meeting and if it is unanimously passed then the meeting does not have to be held.

Financial Statements

A corporation and its directors are required by law to produce and publicize annual financial statements under s. 198(2) of the BCA, ensuring that the financial statements are prepared properly. Section 199(1) provides that financial statements are to be approved and signed by the directors before they are published and completed with an auditor’s report. Section 200(1)(a) of the BCA allows directors to be relieved of this obligation if all shareholders unanimously resolve to waive the requirement.

Director Elections and Appointing an Auditor

Every annual filing requires that at least one director be appointed to the corporation. This needs to be shown in the documents of the annual general meeting. Section 203(1) of the BCA requires that every corporation have an auditor and the auditor has to report on the financial statements of the corporation, s. 212(1). Hiring an auditor for a small corporation can be an expense that is unnecessary. The act does allow a corporation to waive the need for an auditor, as per s. 203(2). To waive the requirement all shareholders must unanimously resolve to waive the requirement on the resolution.

 

If you need professional consultation to understand your legal responsibilities when choosing to incorporate your business, contact Heath Law, in Nanaimo, BC or read more commercial law articles here.

June 13, 2024/by Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers
/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png 0 0 Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers /wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers2024-06-13 14:57:022024-06-18 09:23:01What annual documents need to be prepared for a corporation in B.C.?

I have a small business, what are the advantages of incorporation?

Blog, Business and Commercial Law

Advantages of Incorporation for Small Businesses

As a small business grows, there are risks of personal liability. The act of Incorporating a business is one way to mitigate personal liability. Limited liability is not the only advantage that incorporation provides. This post explores the advantages of incorporation, focusing on its legal, financial and operational benefits.

Limited Liability Protection

Incorporation establishes the business as a distinct legal entity, separate from its owners. This pivotal separation shields personal assets from business liabilities and debts. Incorporations offer some protection from potential lawsuits or financial encumbrances, bolstering financial security and risk management.

Transfer of Ownership Interests

The ownership of corporations is generally in the form of shares, rather than holding specific assets. Shares permit increased flexibility in ownership transitions, which may enable smoother succession planning or acquisitions.

Unlimited Life Span

Provided the corporation maintains its registration with the provincial government (as the case may be), it has an everlasting existence. This is in contrast to other forms of business, such as a sole proprietorship where the business may dissolve upon the owner’s demise, and corporations sustain operational continuity.

Enhanced Credibility

Incorporating signifies a commitment to long-term business viability, enhancing credibility among stakeholders. The enduring corporate structure conveys stability and reliability, instilling confidence in investors, lenders, employees, suppliers, and customers alike. This credibility may foster stronger business relationships and growth opportunities.

Improved Access to Financing and Tax Benefits

Corporations attract greater attention from investors and lenders due to their transparent organizational structure. Moreover, corporations may leverage tax advantages such as lower tax rates, deductions, and income splitting among shareholders.

Provincial vs. Federal Incorporation

The choice between provincial and federal incorporation hinges on the business’s expansion plans and operational scope. Local businesses with limited geographical reach may opt for provincial incorporation, while those considering national or international expansion may benefit from federal incorporation.

The above list is just a small sampling of the advantages of incorporation for small businesses. Heath Law’s team of commercial and business law experts can provide the legal advice you need for your small business type.

Contact us to book an appointment with one of our lawyers today or read more commercial law blogs.

June 10, 2024/by Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers
/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png 0 0 Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers /wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers2024-06-10 16:10:172024-06-10 16:20:39I have a small business, what are the advantages of incorporation?

What are the tax implications of buying a business, and how can I minimize them?

Blog, Business and Commercial Law

When purchasing a business it is essential for buyers to consider the potential tax implications and strategies to minimize them. Two key tax considerations are the Goods and Services Tax (GST) and provincial sales tax (PST). The method of acquisition, whether through share or asset transfer, significantly impacts the tax outcome. In general, when buying a business by transferring shares, GST is often exempt, as shares are considered financial instruments. However, in asset transfers, the GST exemption does not apply, so careful evaluation of the transaction is necessary to determine GST obligations. To further complicate matters, the choice between share and asset transactions can also affect provincial sales tax liabilities. Real estate holdings within the business, for instance, can significantly impact property transfer tax costs.

To navigate these complexities and minimize tax burdens, buyers should conduct a thorough tax assessment and consider seeking professional guidance to make informed decisions during the acquisition process. An asset purchase as opposed to a share purchase can be better for the buyer when considering potential tax implications, however, it tends to cost the seller more. Therefore, a seller may demand a higher price in an asset deal to offset its reduced proceeds.

In a share purchase transaction, the purchaser becomes responsible for any unpaid GST, source deductions and income tax that was to be paid by the target company. These tax compliance matters could expose the purchaser to significant liabilities after the share purchase. Reviewing all financial matters including tax compliance by your tax/accounting consultant is essential. Unknown tax liabilities could be mitigated by a holdback (from the purchase proceeds) to be held for a set period of time after the share purchase to meet any unknown tax obligations.

November 7, 2023/by Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers
/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png 0 0 Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers /wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers2023-11-07 18:00:412023-11-07 18:00:41What are the tax implications of buying a business, and how can I minimize them?

What intellectual property considerations are important in a business acquisition?

Blog, Business and Commercial Law

When acquiring a business, prospective buyers should give careful attention to the realm of intellectual property (IP). Protecting and leveraging these intangible assets is paramount. A buyer would do well to consider any trademarks, and whether they are owned by the business or individuals, and to ensure they are registered. A buyer should evaluate the business’s brand recognition in the market.

They should also assess patents and inventions, scrutinize copyrighted material, and confirm ownership and usage rights. A buyer of a business should not overlook the safeguarding of trade secrets and confidential information, as these may be pivotal to the business’s success.

Moreover, to further ensure the value of the business the buyer is looking to acquire, they should delve into the web of existing non-compete and non-disclosure agreements, as they could impact the business’s post-acquisition operations.

The buyer should examine licensing agreements and the potential need for updates. During the due diligence process, the buyer should uncover any lingering IP issues, such as disputes or potential or ongoing lawsuits. Post-acquisition, the buyer may wish to chart a clear IP strategy to maximize the value of the assets, including any purchased IP, and potentially expand the business’s IP portfolio.

Collaborating with legal experts and IP professionals will help ensure a seamless transition and long-term protection for your intellectual property investments.

November 7, 2023/by Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers
/wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png 0 0 Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers /wp-content/uploads/2017/05/Heath-Law-Logo-300x75.png Heath Law, Nanaimo Lawyers2023-11-07 17:54:232023-11-07 17:54:43What intellectual property considerations are important in a business acquisition?
Page 1 of 6123›»
Search Search

Recent Posts

  • Directors’ Duties, Corporate Governance in British Columbia, and Personal Liabilities of a Director of a Corporation
  • Directors of BC Societies: Your Duties and Personal Liability
  • What Should Be Found In A Franchise Disclosure Document?
  • Separation And Divorce In BC: Property, Parenting Time, And Support Basics
  • Property Line And Neighbour Disputes In BC: Fences, Trees, And Boundaries

Categories

  • Accidents
  • Adoption
  • Blog
  • Business and Commercial Law
  • Child Support
  • Divorce Law
  • Employment Law
  • Family Law
  • Gifts
  • Homeowner Liability
  • Litigation
  • Medical Assistance in Dying
  • Parenting
  • Pedestrians
  • Personal Injury
  • Power of Attorney
  • Property
  • Real Estate
  • Small Claims Court
  • Spousal Support
  • Trusts And Estates Law
  • Wills

Archives

  • November 2026
  • September 2026
  • January 2026
  • December 2025
  • September 2025
  • July 2025
  • April 2025
  • September 2024
  • August 2024
  • July 2024
  • June 2024
  • November 2023
  • October 2023
  • September 2023
  • August 2023
  • July 2023
  • December 2022
  • October 2022
  • August 2022
  • July 2022
  • June 2022
  • March 2022
  • January 2022
  • October 2021
  • September 2021
  • August 2021
  • May 2021
  • December 2020
  • November 2020
  • October 2020
  • July 2020
  • April 2020
  • February 2020
  • November 2019
  • October 2019
  • September 2019
  • August 2019
  • July 2019
  • June 2019
  • May 2019
  • March 2019
  • January 2019
  • December 2018
  • November 2018
  • October 2018
  • September 2018
  • July 2018
  • June 2018
  • April 2018
  • February 2018
  • January 2018
  • December 2017
  • November 2017
  • October 2017
  • September 2017
  • April 2017
  • February 2017
  • December 2016
  • November 2016
  • October 2016
  • September 2016
  • June 2016
  • March 2016

Nanaimo Personal Injury Lawyers & Family Law

Accidents Adoption Blog Business and Commercial Law Child Support Divorce Law Employment Law Family Law Gifts Homeowner Liability Litigation Medical Assistance in Dying Parenting Pedestrians Personal Injury Power of Attorney Property Real Estate Small Claims Court Spousal Support Trusts And Estates Law Wills

Heath Law LLP

Heath Law LLP is a full service law firm that opened in Nanaimo on Vancouver Island in 1950. We are proud of our heritage. Six of our lawyers have been appointed to the Supreme Court of British Columbia, four as Judges, one as an Associate Judge and one as a Judicial Justice. Heath Law LLP boasts high calibre and experienced legal counsel.

Recent Posts

  • Directors’ Duties, Corporate Governance in British Columbia, and Personal Liabilities of a Director of a Corporation
  • Directors of BC Societies: Your Duties and Personal Liability
  • What Should Be Found In A Franchise Disclosure Document?
  • Separation And Divorce In BC: Property, Parenting Time, And Support Basics
  • Property Line And Neighbour Disputes In BC: Fences, Trees, And Boundaries

Subscribe to our Newsletter

Contact Info

Address: 200-1808 Bowen Road Nanaimo, British Columbia
V9S 5W4

Phone: 250-753-2202
Toll Free: 1-866-753-2202
Fax: 250-753-3949
Email: consult@nanaimolaw.com

© Copyright Nanaimo Law | Heath Law. - All Rights Reserved | Website by Webacom
  • Home
  • About Us
  • Lawyers
  • Services
  • Blog
  • Contact Us
  • Privacy Policy
  • Sitemap
Scroll to top Scroll to top Scroll to top