Hiring a contractor to perform work around your house or property can be a long and complicated process. It is worse when the work is not done properly, resulting in delays or requiring repairs to the work completed by the contractor. If a contractor refuses to remedy the defects, a lawsuit might be the best option to ensure that you are compensated appropriately for the breach of contract. If you ultimately decide to sue the contractor, a Court will determine if the contractor acted negligently when performing the work.

The Provincial  Court of British Columbia provides a good summation of the law in the case of Morgan and Gaiga v. Pacific Coast Floor Covering Inc., 2018 BCPC 236. In that case, the Court was considering if flooring had been installed negligently. When determining if the flooring had been installed negligently, the Court opined that a contractor is required to perform the work to a usually ascertained objective standard. A contractor, when completing a job, must ensure that:

  1. The materials are of proper quality
  2. The work is performed in a good and workmanlike manner;
  3. The materials and work, when completed, must be fit for their intended purposes; and
  4. The work must be completed without undue delay.

When determining if work is completed to the standard required by law, a Court will consider a broad category of factors. A Court will consider the industry standards associated with that particular type of construction, any regulatory standards for the work performed, or the manufacturer’s installation instructions for the product. When considering these elements, no one element will be determinative, but a Court will attempt to determine if the contractor performed the work negligently. Ultimately, the Court did find that the flooring was not installed with generallyaccepted practices and standards in the industry.For example, the Court reviewed the manufacturer’s Installation Instructions and the industry standards adopted by the Canadian Wood Flooring Association. Consequently, the Court awarded a judgment to repair the negligent flooring.

If you have concerns regarding work completed in or around your home, please give us a call to discuss the matter. Deciding on the best course of legal action will require a careful analysis of the specific circumstances.